A U.S. District Judge has dismissed President Donald Trump’s defamation lawsuit against The Wall Street Journal concerning a story about a birthday card he allegedly sent to convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. Judge Darrin Gayles, based in Miami, ruled that Trump failed to demonstrate that the defendants made defamatory statements with actual malice, a requirement for such claims under U.S. law.
This marks the second time that Trump's lawsuit has been dismissed. The judge noted that the lawsuit, which was originally filed in response to a 2025 report by the paper, did not meet the legal standards necessary to proceed. In his ruling, Judge Gayles emphasized that Trump’s claims "fall short of pleading actual malice," which is a critical component in defamation cases involving public figures.S3
The case revolved around a letter purportedly written and signed by Trump to Epstein as part of a birthday book, which the Wall Street Journal reported on in 2025. The dismissal with prejudice means that Trump cannot refile the same claims in the future, effectively closing the door on this legal battle.S4