A South Carolina judge has declined to dismiss the murder indictments against Alex Murdaugh, delivering another setback to the disgraced former attorney ahead of his retrial. Circuit Court Judge Debra McCaslin issued her ruling on Friday, Nov. 13, after a pretrial hearing in which Murdaugh's lawyers argued that SLED investigator David Owen had misled the grand jury about blood-spatter evidence and shotgun ammunition.
McCaslin acknowledged that the state made significant errors in presenting evidence to the grand jury, including inaccurate ammunition testimony. She said there was no indication the errors were deliberate, and concluded that the remaining unchallenged evidence overwhelmingly established probable cause. She also sharply criticized Owen for failing to account for a laboratory report addressed directly to him before testifying, writing that such oversights undermine public confidence in the criminal justice system.S1S2
The defense alleged that Owen told the grand jury there was blood spatter on the shirt Murdaugh wore on June 7, 2021, the day his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul, were killed at the family's Moselle property in Colleton County, even though testing failed to detect human blood on the garment. Owen testified at the earlier trial that he did not intend to mislead jurors and had not reviewed the final SLED laboratory report until after the indictment was issued. Prosecutors argued that negative blood-test results did not necessarily disprove the findings, citing an expert who said earlier chemical treatment may have caused false negatives.S1S2
McCaslin ruled that the disputed evidence can be challenged through cross-examination and impeachment at trial rather than through pretrial dismissal. The retrial, which followed the South Carolina Supreme Court's overturning of Murdaugh's 2023 murder convictions over jury interference, has been set for April 5, 2027, in Sumter County after McCaslin granted a change of venue. Prosecutors said they were prepared to seek another set of grand jury indictments if needed.S1S2