Story Turkey Climate COP31

Climate talks in Turkey collapse after dispute over fossil fuels

Turkey
The brief

U.N. climate talks in Antalya, Turkey, broke down on Sunday after the European Union and other nations rejected a draft agreement meant to set out countries' commitments on climate change, in a row over fossil fuels. Delegates from 196 countries and the European Union had struggled for days to agree on new pledges and on how to deliver earlier promises, and the conference had been due to end two days earlier.

COP31 President Murat Kurum, who is also Turkey's environment minister, said there would be no new draft after a fourth text was rejected. "There is nothing to do, we did all that we could," he said. "We will not be carrying out work on a new text in an environment where there is no consensus." Chris Bowen, the Australian minister leading negotiations, said there were "unbridgeable red lines" and described the geopolitical climate as the most complicated and fraught in living memory.S2

The latest 12-page draft set out proposed measures to accelerate climate action but made no mention of moving away from fossil fuels, a key demand of the E.U. and other nations. Irish minister Darragh O'Brien, speaking for the E.U., said the bloc "strongly objects" to the deal, calling it "greenwashing". Panama and the Marshall Islands also rejected the text, and the United Kingdom delegation called it the "lowest common denominator". All countries had to agree for the text to pass.S2

The talks became the longest in COP history, surpassing the delay at COP25 in Madrid. The summit began on Nov 9. A first draft circulated a week later mentioned fossil fuels six times, but a second draft published on Thursday removed every reference, angering many countries. The conference officially ended on Friday without an agreement, and a fourth draft released on Sunday still contained no mention of fossil fuels.S2

Saudi Arabia, Russia and India have pushed back against including any reference to fossil fuels, citing concerns that phasing them out, which are central to their economies, could pose a financial risk. The divide, described in the Financial Times as a fracture between an Arab group and the EU-led coalition, leaves the question of how to phase out fossil fuels unresolved.S1S2

Timeline · newest first
32m Ft

Climate talks fail after stand-off over fossil fuels

Geopolitical divides laid bare in fracture between Arab group and EU-led coalition

1h Nbcnews

COP31 climate talks break down after angry dispute over fossil fuels

Climate action talks in Turkey broke down Sunday after the European Union and other nations rejected an agreement intended to set out countries’ commitments to tackling climate cha…

Climate talks in Turkey collapse after dispute over fossil fuels

2 outlets 2 reports
The brief

U.N. climate talks in Antalya, Turkey, broke down on Sunday after the European Union and other nations rejected a draft agreement meant to set out countries' commitments on climate change, in a row over fossil fuels. Delegates from 196 countries and the European Union had struggled for days to agree on new pledges and on how to deliver earlier promises, and the conference had been due to end two days earlier.

COP31 President Murat Kurum, who is also Turkey's environment minister, said there would be no new draft after a fourth text was rejected. "There is nothing to do, we did all that we could," he said. "We will not be carrying out work on a new text in an environment where there is no consensus." Chris Bowen, the Australian minister leading negotiations, said there were "unbridgeable red lines" and described the geopolitical climate as the most complicated and fraught in living memory.S2

The latest 12-page draft set out proposed measures to accelerate climate action but made no mention of moving away from fossil fuels, a key demand of the E.U. and other nations. Irish minister Darragh O'Brien, speaking for the E.U., said the bloc "strongly objects" to the deal, calling it "greenwashing". Panama and the Marshall Islands also rejected the text, and the United Kingdom delegation called it the "lowest common denominator". All countries had to agree for the text to pass.S2

The talks became the longest in COP history, surpassing the delay at COP25 in Madrid. The summit began on Nov 9. A first draft circulated a week later mentioned fossil fuels six times, but a second draft published on Thursday removed every reference, angering many countries. The conference officially ended on Friday without an agreement, and a fourth draft released on Sunday still contained no mention of fossil fuels.S2

Saudi Arabia, Russia and India have pushed back against including any reference to fossil fuels, citing concerns that phasing them out, which are central to their economies, could pose a financial risk. The divide, described in the Financial Times as a fracture between an Arab group and the EU-led coalition, leaves the question of how to phase out fossil fuels unresolved.S1S2

Timeline · newest first

Sources · 2 citations

S1 Ft 1 report · EN
S2 NbcnewsLead 1 report · EN
Share this story

Climate talks in Turkey collapse after dispute over fossil fuels