Tyler Perry's 'The Gospel of Christmas' is a musical drama of faith that a reviewer found earnest and generically reverential, lacking the Madea characters and the soap-opera extravagance that fans might expect from a Perry Christmas film. The reviewer said the story of losing, testing and regaining faith is wrapped around a family saga that feels rickety and threadbare, closer to a Sunday sermon padded out to movie length.
The film stars Durrell 'Tank' Babbs as Isaac Jefferson, a former bad-boy pop singer whose biggest hit was 'Gimme Them Panties' and whose career faded 20 years earlier, a backstory the reviewer said the film never convincingly fills in. Isaac's clergyman father, on his deathbed, asks him to take over the Baptist church of his great-grandfather in New York City. Isaac, reluctant to become a pastor, moves with his wife Rebecca, played by Fantasia Barrino, and their two sons from Georgia to the city.S1S2
Once there, Isaac finds the stone church is five months behind on rent and faces penalties and taxes, with $58,000 needed to keep it running. The reviewer said his deeper burden is that he has forgotten how to pray and how to believe, a mood the reviewer described as mopey and repetitive for the lead character across the 90-minute runtime.S1S2
The gospel and soul numbers, which carry the action along, include some lovely songs and a couple of pop-gospel rousers, but the reviewer said their mood is so out of step with the rest of the film that they seem to belong to another movie, breaking up the drama rather than lifting it.S1S2