Are Scotland still too reliant on the 'old guard'?

United Kingdom
The brief

Switzerland cruised to a heavy win over Scotland in St Gallen, with Zeki Amdouni scoring the second-string hosts' fourth, a result that left the Scottish camp in a deflated mood. Andy Robertson, who was winning his record-breaking 103rd cap as captain, was among the players left to face the media afterwards, alongside John McGinn, Kieran Tierney and Billy Gilmour. The body language of Robertson and Ryan Christie in the immediate aftermath was, by all accounts, telling.

The defeat came during a first campaign for head coach Sebastien Pocognoli, who had been praised for breaking with convention in his first squad by bringing in young players. In the match, however, those younger players were largely restricted to the bench, with Pocognoli turning to the established core. Former Scotland international Leanne Crichton, speaking on BBC Scotland's Sportscene, said there was still a clear reliance on that key group of players, and that they sounded dejected and unsure about what was happening.S2S3

Scotland had been goalless despite a handful of chances, and a narrow half-time deficit became a heavier defeat by the final whistle. McGinn, who had scored Scotland's last three goals, sent a weak header goalwards before the break, while Scott McTominay missed a couple of clear opportunities, nearly a year after his Hampden heroics against Denmark. Crichton argued that results depend heavily on those players performing, including McGinn and the midfield pairing of Gilmour and Ferguson, and that a different kind of confidence needs to be built within the wider squad.S2S3

Kieron Bowie, whom many had expected to start, came on just before the hour mark. Winger Ben Gannon-Doak, who had been dropped in favour of Aaron Hickey, came on after Hickey went off with an apparent hamstring injury, and Kristi Montgomery was handed a debut with five minutes remaining. Wide players Findlay Curtis and Josh McPake were again left on the bench, while Robbie Ure did not make either matchday squad this camp.S2S3

Timeline · newest first
56m Wol

Nations League: Are Scotland still too reliant on ‘old guard’?

Football Nations League: Are Scotland still too reliant on ‘old guard’? November 17, 2026 admin 5 Views 0 Comments Kieron Bowie, who many hoped would be in from the off, came on ju…

1h Yahoo Sports

Are Scotland still too reliant on 'old guard'?

After a bruising defeat in Switzerland to conclude Scotland's Nations League campaign, questions are being asked about the direction of travel under new head coach Sebastien Pocagn…

1h BBC

Are Scotland still too reliant on 'old guard'?

After a bruising defeat in Switzerland to conclude Scotland's Nations League campaign, questions are being asked about the direction of travel under new head coach Sebastien Pocagn…

Breaking

Are Scotland still too reliant on the 'old guard'?

3 outlets 3 reports
The brief

Switzerland cruised to a heavy win over Scotland in St Gallen, with Zeki Amdouni scoring the second-string hosts' fourth, a result that left the Scottish camp in a deflated mood. Andy Robertson, who was winning his record-breaking 103rd cap as captain, was among the players left to face the media afterwards, alongside John McGinn, Kieran Tierney and Billy Gilmour. The body language of Robertson and Ryan Christie in the immediate aftermath was, by all accounts, telling.

The defeat came during a first campaign for head coach Sebastien Pocognoli, who had been praised for breaking with convention in his first squad by bringing in young players. In the match, however, those younger players were largely restricted to the bench, with Pocognoli turning to the established core. Former Scotland international Leanne Crichton, speaking on BBC Scotland's Sportscene, said there was still a clear reliance on that key group of players, and that they sounded dejected and unsure about what was happening.S2S3

Scotland had been goalless despite a handful of chances, and a narrow half-time deficit became a heavier defeat by the final whistle. McGinn, who had scored Scotland's last three goals, sent a weak header goalwards before the break, while Scott McTominay missed a couple of clear opportunities, nearly a year after his Hampden heroics against Denmark. Crichton argued that results depend heavily on those players performing, including McGinn and the midfield pairing of Gilmour and Ferguson, and that a different kind of confidence needs to be built within the wider squad.S2S3

Kieron Bowie, whom many had expected to start, came on just before the hour mark. Winger Ben Gannon-Doak, who had been dropped in favour of Aaron Hickey, came on after Hickey went off with an apparent hamstring injury, and Kristi Montgomery was handed a debut with five minutes remaining. Wide players Findlay Curtis and Josh McPake were again left on the bench, while Robbie Ure did not make either matchday squad this camp.S2S3

Timeline · newest first

Sources · 3 citations

S1 Wol 1 report · EN
S2 Yahoo Sports 1 report · EN
S3 BBCLead 1 report · EN