A 30-year-old man has been found not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter of Anthony, also known as Josh, Fowler, a recovering drug addict who was 63 years old when he was stabbed to death in Finglas, Dublin, on November 26, 2024. The verdict was returned by a majority of 10 to 2 by a jury at the Central Criminal Court, following a trial that began on October 16.
Ryan Brennan, of Lanesborough Gardens in Finglas, had pleaded not guilty to murder. The State's case was that he was part of a joint enterprise with his younger half-brother, Connor Brennan Moran, to cause serious injury to Mr Fowler, whom they believed had stolen cannabis and cash. The State alleged that Mr Fowler was stabbed by one of the two men in a case of common design. Connor Brennan Moran, 23, of Lanesborough Square, pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to manslaughter, a plea the State did not accept. After five days of deliberation the jury failed to reach a verdict on his charge, and a disagreement was recorded on the issue paper.S1
The jury of six men and six women deliberated for 12 hours and 52 minutes over five days. Mr Justice Patrick McGrath thanked them for their care in what he described as a difficult case, and exempted them from jury service for the next ten years. Before they left, he told them the consequences of their decision were now for someone else.S1
Both defendants remain in custody. Prosecutor Garrett McCormack SC said a further date for mention would be needed for Connor Brennan Moran. For Ryan Brennan, his counsel Brendan Grehan SC said a probation report might assist, and the court directed one, with the matter put back to a date in December. Mr Justice McGrath said both cases should travel together for the moment.S1