David O. Russell's biopic "Madden" has drawn sharply different reactions from critics. Variety's review describes Nicolas Cage as playing the Oakland Raiders coach and later television commentator under a heavy prosthetic fatsuit, calling the performance two parts impersonation and one part Cage kabuki. The reviewer characterises the film as a stunt biopic that feels like an extended Saturday Night Live sketch played straight, but shot and edited with the energy of Scorsese, with mock documentary interviews, Madden diagramming plays directly on screen, and period needle drops such as "How Long" and "Evil Ways" in the style of Casino.
The film's portrayal of Raiders owner Al Davis, played by Christian Bale with a shark-like mouth, slicked-back hair and a Jewish goombah accent, is described by Variety as a fellow monomaniac rather than a criminal, with the two sustaining a testy friendship even after Madden leaves the team. Variety expects the film to struggle in theaters, with a modest release, but suggests it could find an audience on streaming, where it argues the movie's obsessive energy is best suited. Sienna Miller appears as Davis's wife, and the reviewer praises Cage for bringing the film's sense of obsession to life.S1
TheWrap's review takes a far less generous view, calling "Madden" one of the most insubstantial biopics in an era defined by them. The review notes that Madden took the Oakland Raiders to their first Super Bowl win in the 1970s, became a major figure in television commentary after retiring, and was a central presence in the EA "Madden NFL" video game series, which the film touches on. The reviewer argues the film skips Madden's early years, drops him in the mid-1970s and offers little conflict, with Madden's career setbacks, including an ulcer that forces his retirement from coaching, resolved too easily.S2
TheWrap finds Nicolas Cage adorable but largely unchallenged in the role, and says Christian Bale gives the more interesting performance as Davis, a figure who looks like a disreputable creep but is a softie. The review singles out Kathryn Hahn, who plays Madden's wife Virginia, as the film's real source of personality, noting that director Russell cuts repeatedly to her exasperated stares into the camera. Taken together, the two reviews agree that the film is watchable and built around its performances, while disagreeing sharply on whether its eccentric style delivers depth or merely plays it safe.S1S2