Mamdani's Decision to Disband NYPD Strategic Response Group Draws Sharp Criticism

United States
The brief

New York City Mayor Mamdani announced on Monday that the NYPD's Strategic Response Group, a special police unit, would be disbanded, saying he had promised during his 2025 campaign to separate counterterrorism from protest response. He said New Yorkers exercising their constitutional right to protest should not face the same police response as a terrorism threat.

The move has drawn strong criticism from opinion writer Michael Goodwin, who argues the decision is rooted in politics and ignores why the unit was created. The Strategic Response Group was established in 2015 by then-Police Commissioner Bill Bratton, and has been maintained by subsequent mayors and by Bratton's successors, including current top cop Jessica Tisch, who has consistently defended the unit.S2

In a column in The Post, Bratton wrote that the unit gave the department a mobile force able to move quickly across the five boroughs in response to major incidents, crime patterns and civil disorder. He cited coordinated terror attacks in Mumbai and Paris as examples of how quickly multiple armed assailants could strike different locations, and said the unit's active-shooter training and equipment were deployed only when an armed attacker threatened lives, not as ordinary tools of protest management.S2

Critics argue that the decision leaves a dangerous gap in the city's readiness for coordinated attacks, while the mayor's supporters frame it as a fulfilment of a campaign promise to separate counterterrorism work from policing of demonstrations.S1S2

Timeline · newest first
42m Realclearpolitics

Mamdani's Twisted Socialist Agenda Endangers NYC

Mayor Mamdani is certainly not my idea of a good public official, but there is no denying his consistency.

Mamdani's Decision to Disband NYPD Strategic Response Group Draws Sharp Criticism

2 outlets 2 reports
The brief

New York City Mayor Mamdani announced on Monday that the NYPD's Strategic Response Group, a special police unit, would be disbanded, saying he had promised during his 2025 campaign to separate counterterrorism from protest response. He said New Yorkers exercising their constitutional right to protest should not face the same police response as a terrorism threat.

The move has drawn strong criticism from opinion writer Michael Goodwin, who argues the decision is rooted in politics and ignores why the unit was created. The Strategic Response Group was established in 2015 by then-Police Commissioner Bill Bratton, and has been maintained by subsequent mayors and by Bratton's successors, including current top cop Jessica Tisch, who has consistently defended the unit.S2

In a column in The Post, Bratton wrote that the unit gave the department a mobile force able to move quickly across the five boroughs in response to major incidents, crime patterns and civil disorder. He cited coordinated terror attacks in Mumbai and Paris as examples of how quickly multiple armed assailants could strike different locations, and said the unit's active-shooter training and equipment were deployed only when an armed attacker threatened lives, not as ordinary tools of protest management.S2

Critics argue that the decision leaves a dangerous gap in the city's readiness for coordinated attacks, while the mayor's supporters frame it as a fulfilment of a campaign promise to separate counterterrorism work from policing of demonstrations.S1S2

Timeline · newest first

Sources · 2 citations

S1 Realclearpolitics 1 report · EN
S2 NypostLead 1 report · EN