Tim Strenfel resigned as head football coach of Middletown High School in New York less than a week after his undefeated team was forced to forfeit a Section IX Class AA semifinal playoff win for using an ineligible player for 53 seconds, News 12 and Mid-Hudson News reported. The forfeit ended the team's hopes of completing a perfect season.
Strenfel had led Middletown's football program for 10 years before coming under fire for putting a kicker into the crucial matchup. The player had previously been on the Middletown boys soccer team and joined the football team in the middle of the regular season, which the Middies finished with a 9-1 record. He was eligible for regular-season games but was ruled ineligible for the postseason because he had not appeared on a roster for at least three regular-season games, according to New York State Public High School Athletic Association guidelines.S1S2
Middletown defeated Valley Central 48-15 in the semifinal on Nov. 6. The unidentified athlete, later ruled an ineligible kickoff specialist, appeared in eight plays lasting just under a minute during the win. After the game, coaches at Newburgh Free Academy, Middletown's original championship opponent, spotted the unfamiliar player and alerted Valley Central officials. Valley Central's athletic director reported the alleged violation to Section IX officials, who ordered Middletown to forfeit.S1S2
The Middies appealed the ruling and took the matter to State Supreme Court, but withdrew their petition after learning a judge was not expected to rule in their favor. Middletown officials called the forfeiture "arbitrary and capricious," arguing that an adult's error had punished the players. Superintendent Amy Creeden said, "While we are deeply, deeply disappointed that we are unable to find a remedy for our young people, our hearts are with our football team and cheerleading scholars who have given so much to this remarkable football season and cheerleading season."S1S2
Valley Central took Middletown's place in the Section IX Class AA final, defeating Newburgh Free Academy 16-6 at Monroe-Woodbury on Nov. 14. The Vikings will face Christian Brothers Academy in a regional championship game on Nov. 21.S1S2