A federal judge on Thursday ordered Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins to stop sending Christian exhortations and Scripture verses to her department's roughly 100,000 employees, ruling that the missives violated the First Amendment. The ruling came in a 21-page decision by US District Judge Trina Thompson in San Francisco.
Rollins, a Texas native and devout Christian, had repeatedly used USDA communications to promote her religious beliefs, including in messages marking Christmas, Easter and Thanksgiving. In an April 5 Easter email, first reported by POLITICO, she celebrated the resurrection of Jesus Christ and compared USDA workers to the first disciples who encountered the risen Lord in the Upper Room. In a Dec. 23, 2025 email, she included a video message describing the gift of God's Son and Savior as the source of generosity.S2
Thompson said Rollins' use of government communications, combined with her position, amounted to pressuring employees to adopt her religious beliefs or conceal their own. She took special issue with Rollins' use of "we," "us" and "our," which she said suggested Christianity was a shared belief among USDA employees. The secretary did not send comparable messages recognizing other religious holidays.S2
Seven USDA workers and the National Federation of Federal Employees union sued Rollins in May, arguing she was subjecting them to government-sponsored religious coercion. The group of multifaith and nonreligious employees also argued they could not simply ignore the messages, since Rollins used the same official channels to deliver important announcements. Thompson agreed that the emails suggested acquiescence amounting to coercive pressure sufficient to raise an Establishment Clause violation.S2
Citing the USDA's own workplace religious-expression policy, the judge said Rollins must stop such conversations if asked, cannot make persistent unwelcome advances related to religion, and cannot use her position to pressure subordinates. The USDA called the ruling an unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet Secretary and said it was considering an appeal.S2