The Office of the Vice President on Saturday, November 21, denied any link between its "Pagbabago: A Million Trees Campaign" and Cale88 Foods Corp.'s compliance with a Board of Investments tree-planting requirement for businesses seeking incentives. The statement followed questioning by impeachment prosecutors on the 45th day of Vice President Sara Duterte's trial, when private prosecutor Erwin Matib showed photos of Duterte planting trees during the cross-examination of Department of Trade and Industry Undersecretary Ceferino Rodolfo, who also heads the BOI.
The OVP called any attempt to link the Vice President's participation in its environmental initiatives to Cale88's BOI compliance "misleading, malicious, and has no factual basis." It said the campaign was launched on March 27, 2023, as an independent environmental initiative supporting the Department of Environment and Natural Resources' efforts to reduce carbon emissions and address climate change, and that it has planted 1,386,682 trees nationwide with government agencies and private-sector partners.S1S2
House prosecution spokesperson Zia Adiong defended the questioning on Saturday, saying it was meant to ascertain that the photo had nothing to do with the BOI requirement for Cale88. He described such questions as part of regular cross-examination and told reporters not to be "onion-skinned." Defense counsel Justin Nicol Gular had earlier objected to the line of questioning, calling it misleading, malicious and callous.S1S2
The dispute arose as senator-judges scrutinized Cale88's records under Article II of the impeachment articles, which covers allegations involving Duterte's unexplained wealth and her family's business interests. Cale88, a banana chips exporter declared as a business interest of Duterte's husband, Manases Carpio, has drawn scrutiny over its profits with only two employees and supposed financial inflows from China. Rodolfo could not explain why the company recorded P776.64 million in bank inflows from 2022 to 2025 despite declaring only P208.49 million in sales.S1S2