Independent review ordered into NHS Grampian liver surgery concerns after whistleblower allegations

United Kingdom
The brief

The Scottish Government has ordered an urgent, fully independent review into how concerns about hepatobiliary (HPB) surgery at NHS Grampian were handled, after whistleblower surgeon Dr Mohammed Habib claimed hundreds of patients may have suffered significant harm or avoidable deaths at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary. His lawyer, Aamer Anwar, said the operating theatre had become a "slaughterhouse".

The review will examine how both NHS Grampian and the Scottish Government responded, including an unpublished 2022 expert report that identified 19 avoidable deaths among 45 patients who underwent liver and pancreatic operations. Dr Habib's own account of the report put the figure at 19 avoidable deaths among 31 deaths in liver and pancreatic surgery cases, and he said two people had died after receiving the wrong procedure. Health Secretary Angela Constance said the review would establish who knew what, when they knew it, what action was taken and why, and would scrutinise whether ministers were given adequate information and advice.S1S3

Dr Habib, who has worked in medicine for 36 years, went public at a press conference in Glasgow, saying he was prepared to put his career on the line to demand accountability and reveal what he believes has been a cover-up. He said he had written four letters to the SNP Government, including one to then-First Minister Humza Yousaf in 2023 and three to John Swinney in October 2024, November 2025 and May this year. First Minister John Swinney said he only became aware of the correspondence for the first time the previous Thursday, and he has announced a review of how the Government handles correspondence. Dr Habib has also said he went to the police and the Lord Advocate, and that the health board should face a corporate homicide probe.S1S3

Constance said the review would be led by someone fully independent of both NHS Grampian and the Scottish Government, and she is expected to set out its timetable and name the chair when she makes a statement to Holyrood on Tuesday. The Government said action would be taken quickly where required, including referring any issues, potentially including criminality, to the relevant authorities without waiting for the final report. Scottish Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie said the review must establish who knew what and when, including senior ministers, NHS bosses and civil servants. Patients with questions or in need of advice or support have been directed to the NHS Grampian helpline on 08085 202030.S2S3

Timeline · newest first
56m Dailyrecord

Independent review into 'slaughterhouse' hospital ordered by Scottish Government

A probe will examine how NHS Grampian and the Scottish Government handled warnings from whistleblower surgeon Dr Mohammed Habib, who claims patients suffered avoidable deaths at Ab…

1h Wol

Independent review ordered into surgery carried out by NHS Grampian

“Following discussion with the first minister, I am today commissioning an urgent and fully independent review of how concerns about

1h Standard · 2 reports

Independent review ordered after NHS Grampian revelations

Dr Mohammed Habib spoke out this week.

Breaking

Independent review ordered into NHS Grampian liver surgery concerns after whistleblower allegations

3 outlets 4 reports
The brief

The Scottish Government has ordered an urgent, fully independent review into how concerns about hepatobiliary (HPB) surgery at NHS Grampian were handled, after whistleblower surgeon Dr Mohammed Habib claimed hundreds of patients may have suffered significant harm or avoidable deaths at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary. His lawyer, Aamer Anwar, said the operating theatre had become a "slaughterhouse".

The review will examine how both NHS Grampian and the Scottish Government responded, including an unpublished 2022 expert report that identified 19 avoidable deaths among 45 patients who underwent liver and pancreatic operations. Dr Habib's own account of the report put the figure at 19 avoidable deaths among 31 deaths in liver and pancreatic surgery cases, and he said two people had died after receiving the wrong procedure. Health Secretary Angela Constance said the review would establish who knew what, when they knew it, what action was taken and why, and would scrutinise whether ministers were given adequate information and advice.S1S3

Dr Habib, who has worked in medicine for 36 years, went public at a press conference in Glasgow, saying he was prepared to put his career on the line to demand accountability and reveal what he believes has been a cover-up. He said he had written four letters to the SNP Government, including one to then-First Minister Humza Yousaf in 2023 and three to John Swinney in October 2024, November 2025 and May this year. First Minister John Swinney said he only became aware of the correspondence for the first time the previous Thursday, and he has announced a review of how the Government handles correspondence. Dr Habib has also said he went to the police and the Lord Advocate, and that the health board should face a corporate homicide probe.S1S3

Constance said the review would be led by someone fully independent of both NHS Grampian and the Scottish Government, and she is expected to set out its timetable and name the chair when she makes a statement to Holyrood on Tuesday. The Government said action would be taken quickly where required, including referring any issues, potentially including criminality, to the relevant authorities without waiting for the final report. Scottish Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie said the review must establish who knew what and when, including senior ministers, NHS bosses and civil servants. Patients with questions or in need of advice or support have been directed to the NHS Grampian helpline on 08085 202030.S2S3

Timeline · newest first

Sources · 4 citations

S1 Dailyrecord 1 report · EN
S2 Wol 1 report · EN
S3S4 StandardLead 2 reports · EN
Share this story

Independent review ordered into NHS Grampian liver surgery concerns after whistleblower allegations