For the second time this year, Wall Street bankers and lawyers collected a massive paycheck from a record-setting initial public offering, and some of them complained privately that the process was riddled with complications and unlike any they had worked on before. Anthropic's IPO, dubbed internally "Project Lantern", eclipsed SpaceX on Thursday, with bankers taking home more than half a billion dollars in fees.
The complaints echo those surrounding SpaceX's June IPO, in which banks earned half a billion dollars in fees. Bankers in that deal chafed over how tightly the Elon Musk-led company controlled the months-long process and kept financial and other information private, making it hard for advisers to do their jobs.S1S2
People close to the Anthropic process listed a series of problems: a compressed timeline marred by last-minute changes and delays in sharing financial projections, rushed document approvals, and highly unusual restrictions on bankers. Concern about leaks was acute, especially after Reuters reported many details from a draft IPO filing weeks before it was made public. Anthropic instructed some of its 22 IPO underwriters to limit the number of bankers working on the deal to four, asking the firms to make sure they were senior staff. One person said the restriction likely stemmed from fear of leaks, and that the banks found a way to work around it anyway.S1S2
The friction reflects a new power dynamic between technology companies and Wall Street. Companies such as SpaceX and Anthropic, and potentially OpenAI in the future, have gained enormous leverage as the transformative potential of artificial intelligence creates frenzied demand for their shares. Jay Ritter, a University of Florida professor emeritus who researches IPOs, said these companies had market power to tell underwriters it would not be business as usual. He added that the big Wall Street firms would likely continue business as usual with all but perhaps OpenAI after these two deals.S1S2
Both SpaceX and Anthropic negotiated to pay underwriters nothing on the additional shares sold through the greenshoe option, according to Ritter, who said most companies would be unlikely to secure zero spread on overallotment shares. Both debuted successfully, raising record amounts of money, and their shares initially rallied. Anthropic, Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley, the two lead underwriters on the two IPOs, declined to comment. SpaceX and OpenAI did not respond to requests for comment.S1S2