Brazil’s top electoral court has imposed a fine of $1.3 million on Meta’s Facebook for failing to comply with judicial orders during the recent presidential election runoff campaign. The ruling, made late Tuesday, comes after allegations from President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s campaign that Facebook exhibited political bias by treating content from Lula and his challenger, Flávio Bolsonaro, differently. Although the court found no evidence that Facebook attempted to influence the election's outcome, it noted that the company did not adequately meet court demands regarding these allegations.
Justice Marco Aurélio Bellizze, who delivered the ruling, stated that proving intent to influence the election would require compelling evidence to be presented through appropriate legal channels. Lula’s campaign had filed a lawsuit ahead of the runoff, claiming that Facebook, which owns Instagram and WhatsApp, was using biased algorithms and artificial intelligence restrictions to favor Bolsonaro. This claim resonated with Lula's supporters, leading to protests outside Meta’s offices in Sao Paulo.S1S2
In its defense, Meta attributed recent platform issues to unrelated global technical glitches, strict anti-fraud measures, and regulatory compliance rather than any deliberate suppression of content. The company asserted that it had implemented measures to treat both campaigns equally. However, the court found that Meta had not fully complied with some orders, resulting in the significant fine of 7.5 million reais, which corresponds to fines accrued over specific dates during the election period.S1S2
The fine consists of three days of penalties of 500,000 reais ($90,000) from October 17 to 19, followed by six days of fines of 1 million reais ($180,000) from October 20 to 25. In an updated statement prior to the ruling, Meta reiterated its stance, claiming it applies the same rules to all candidates and political viewpoints in Brazil as it does globally. In the runoff, Lula won decisively, defeating Bolsonaro by over 4.4 million votes, a shift attributed to a significant mobilization of his supporters both online and in public demonstrations.S1S2