A Manhattan judge has rejected a lawsuit seeking to reopen College Walk, a once-public path through the Columbia University campus, meaning the university can keep its gates closed to the public. The case was brought by Morningside Heights residents, who argued the university should restore access to the walkway that runs across West 116th Street between Broadway and Amsterdam Avenue. Judge David Cohen dismissed the suit last week, ruling that the residents have "no right" to access College Walk. Although the case is over for now, the residents' attorney, Toby Golick, said, "My clients and I are very disappointed in today's decision, and plan to appeal."
The lawsuit, filed a year ago, rested on a 1953 agreement under which New York City transferred that section of West 116th Street to the university. The residents argued that the deal required the walkway to remain open to the public, and they also claimed that the closure violates disability protections because older and disabled neighbors must now take lengthy detours around the campus. Judge Cohen found nothing in the 1953 agreement that gave the public a right to use the path. In the ruling, he wrote, "Even if Columbia previously granted unrestricted public access to College Walk, as it remained their private property, nothing prevented them from restricting access at any time."S1S2
The restrictions date back to protests in October 2023, after which Columbia first closed its gates to the public. The campus was shut down again in spring 2024, when anti-Israel protesters set up encampments on the university's lawns, prompting police intervention. The gates have remained locked since, guarded by security, and students and faculty now need a Columbia-issued identification card to enter.S1S2
The ruling follows a September warning from Mayor Zohran Mamdani, who grew up in the neighborhood and is the son of a Columbia professor. Mamdani had threatened legal action against the university if it did not reopen its gates. A Columbia spokesperson said the university "very much" welcomed the court's recognition that College Walk is private property, according to a statement provided to the Columbia Daily Spectator.S1S2