Story China Diplomacy

Trump, Xi and Putin Set for Shenzhen Summit as Analysts Question Its Significance

China
The brief

U.S. President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin are expected to meet in Shenzhen on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation meeting, a trilateral gathering that has drawn comparisons to the Yalta Conference of February 1945. Commentators have noted the superficial resemblance of three leaders at one table, while arguing that the parallel largely ends there.

Trump has said he wants the talks to focus on denuclearisation, a framing Beijing has resisted. China argues that its far smaller nuclear arsenal makes it unreasonable to include China in such a process. That disagreement over the agenda points to the difficulty of bringing the three powers into a common framework.S1

Unlike the Allied leaders at Yalta, who commanded armies that were deciding the outcome of a world war and negotiated over territories under occupation, the Shenzhen participants are not engaged in a comparable wartime settlement. Analysts describe them as leaders with incompatible ambitions, unequal capabilities and real constraints, none of whom holds the authority to dispose of other countries' interests. Even the Yalta agreements, commentators note, proved less durable than their famous photographs.S2

Timeline · newest first
1h Feedburner:ndtvprofit Latest

'Yalta 2.0': Trump, Xi And Putin To Meet In Shenzhen; All You Need To Know About Historic Meeting

Trump has said he wants the trilateral talks to focus on denuclearisation, a framing Beijing has resisted, arguing that its far smaller arsenal makes it unreasonable to include Chi…

3h Japantimes

Memo to Trump, Xi and Putin: Shenzhen is not Yalta

The U.S., China and Russia cannot dictate outcomes to countries whose cooperation they need.

Trump, Xi and Putin Set for Shenzhen Summit as Analysts Question Its Significance

2 outlets 2 reports
The brief

U.S. President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin are expected to meet in Shenzhen on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation meeting, a trilateral gathering that has drawn comparisons to the Yalta Conference of February 1945. Commentators have noted the superficial resemblance of three leaders at one table, while arguing that the parallel largely ends there.

Trump has said he wants the talks to focus on denuclearisation, a framing Beijing has resisted. China argues that its far smaller nuclear arsenal makes it unreasonable to include China in such a process. That disagreement over the agenda points to the difficulty of bringing the three powers into a common framework.S1

Unlike the Allied leaders at Yalta, who commanded armies that were deciding the outcome of a world war and negotiated over territories under occupation, the Shenzhen participants are not engaged in a comparable wartime settlement. Analysts describe them as leaders with incompatible ambitions, unequal capabilities and real constraints, none of whom holds the authority to dispose of other countries' interests. Even the Yalta agreements, commentators note, proved less durable than their famous photographs.S2

Timeline · newest first

Sources · 2 citations

S2 JapantimesLead 1 report · EN