The Transportation Workers Union, which represents the roughly 200 drivers of horse-drawn carriages in New York City, has filed a class-action suit in Manhattan federal court seeking to undo a ban on the industry. The union argues the measure strips horse-carriage owners of the city-issued medallions they bought for hundreds of thousands of dollars, without mandating or guaranteeing compensation.
TWU International President John Samuelsen called the bill "an unconstitutional abomination." He said the law, as passed, does nothing to ensure the livelihood of the drivers, despite claims from the administration that buy-backs for medallions and stipends would be provided. Samuelsen said the protections the mayor recently outlined should have been written into the legislation.S2
The new law was dubbed Romanch's Law in honor of an 18-year-old tourist killed earlier this year by an out-of-control carriage in Central Park. The union criticised lawmakers for singling out the carriage industry over one-off incidents while, in its view, leaving e-bikes largely unregulated. According to the suit, between 2019 and May 2026 there were 17,434 e-bike injuries and 113 deaths.S2