Jamie Lloyd's production of "Much Ado About Nothing" opened at the Winter Garden Theatre on Broadway, starring Tom Hiddleston as Benedick and Hayley Atwell as Beatrice, after a run in London. The Winter Garden production, which reviewers describe as a boisterous party, begins with dancing ushers, pop music and a stage covered in pink confetti.
Reviewers praise Hiddleston's performance, with one describing his Benedick as relaxed and self-deprecating, making Shakespeare's iambic pentameter sound as easily digested as modern dialogue. He is shown burying himself in confetti during the scene where Benedick overhears his friends claiming Beatrice loves him, and a set piece featuring a large pink Jeff Koons-style balloon heart, designed by Soutra Gilmour. Gerald Kyd, playing Don Pedro, is also singled out as accessible to American audiences.S1S2
Reviews are more divided on Atwell, with the Wrap critic calling her Beatrice uncommonly stiff, while the New York Post praises the cast's energy and the production's habit of breaking the fourth wall, which draws louder audience responses to the witty insults. Lloyd's staging also includes reinterpreted characters, including a sexually fluid Margaret played by Mason Alexander Park, a TikTok-style Hero played by Mara Huf and a tired Don John played by Tim Steed.S1S2
The New York Post notes that the play, which has not been staged on Broadway since the mid-1980s, runs two hours and 20 minutes with one intermission. The Wrap critic says the first act's dancing and pop standards work well, while the second act loses momentum, and faults Lloyd for keeping the brick back wall of the stage exposed in his productions.S1S2